ConcoursMustang Forums

Restoring - General discussions that span across many different groups of years and models => Parts => Topic started by: ChrisV289 on January 18, 2016, 11:20:18 PM

Title: Repro Battery
Post by: ChrisV289 on January 18, 2016, 11:20:18 PM
I noticed the new NPD catalog did not list the Autolite reproduction battery but Virginia Mustang still has it listed on their website.  Is it still being reproduced or are they going to stop soon? 
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: cobrajetchris on January 18, 2016, 11:23:51 PM
The company or companies that make reproduction batteries should all be out of business for selling an over priced boat anchor. I went through 2 in one year and never again. The batteries look nice but if you need to start the car forget about it.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Bob Gaines on January 18, 2016, 11:26:53 PM
I noticed the new NPD catalog did not list the Autolite reproduction battery but Virginia Mustang still has it listed on their website.  Is it still being reproduced or are they going to stop soon?
Not much profit margin from what I understand. Virginia has it drop shipped from MFG. One MFG stopped making them . Only one MFG now I think .
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Bob Gaines on January 18, 2016, 11:31:58 PM
The company or companies that make reproduction batteries should all be out of business for selling an over priced boat anchor. I went through 2 in one year and never again. The batteries look nice but if you need to start the car forget about it.
I would suspect other usage issues at work only because there are many who successfully ( myself included ) use them trouble free for years. With that said they are not near as durable it seems to it's generic counterpart. For example If you let them go dead or almost dead once they are never the same again and don't last long after that . You have to keep them on a tender if you want a extended life IMO.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: jwc66k on January 19, 2016, 12:33:45 AM
The batteries look nice but if you need to start the car forget about it.
Unfortunate but true. I had three Mustangs (one 65 Fastback, 2 66 Fastbacks) with reproduction Autolite type 27 batteries and they lasted about two-three years. The local Excide Battery guy was blunt, you need to drive the cars almost every day to keep that type of battery charged. That's the big secret. I thought a trickle charger would help, it didn't. I currently use a $100 battery with a 48 month warranty instead of a $250 battery with a 90 day warranty in each car. Economics 101.
Jim
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: AIRDRIVERUSA on January 19, 2016, 02:12:25 AM
jac, Bob and Chris...

I do not know if this will help or not but check this web site out.  I believe he gives you a 4 year warranty on battery and they actually look all original.  Hope it helps.

Regards

http://www.restorationbattery.com
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Bob Gaines on January 19, 2016, 02:28:37 AM
jac, Bob and Chris...

I do not know if this will help or not but check this web site out.  I believe he gives you a 4 year warranty on battery and they actually look all original.  Hope it helps.

Regards

http://www.restorationbattery.com
Thanks .the is one i have never seen. gives a pretty good warranty .
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: J_Speegle on January 19, 2016, 02:36:31 AM
.................they actually look all original. .........

Well at least for the 68 and up cars ;)

Anyone try one?
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: 5F08KGT on January 19, 2016, 08:52:56 AM
I too have gone through 2 of the repro batteries trying to keep my car looking somewhat authentic, the last one finally died......so we would use a common battery to start the car, then put the dead repro in at shows.....

I got tired of that and am NOT showing in MCA classes anymore, so I just recently bought the "Better/Best" topper that is on the market, and an EXCIDE battery group 24F in, of all places HOME DEPOT!!

IT HAS the gusset for the original '65 style hold-down bracket!!

I cut off the fabric carry strap, peeled all the stickers off of it, put it in, put the topper on it, hooked it up, and NEVER in 7 years have had the engine turn over so fast!!

40 month FREE REPLACEMENT!!
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: lancelot66 on January 19, 2016, 10:14:45 PM
This past summer I needed to replace ours and had been following these threads and everyone's thoughts, experiences, etc. Decided that until they come out with a more accurate Group 24 or 22, especially the all important top markings and text component associated there, I wasn't going to spend the money. I looked all over the local area for at least one that had the lower lip for the hold-down bracket and as was mentioned, found an Exide Group 24 at Home Depot was the only one, ~$100. So on went the fake topper, peeled off that side decal (very easy), the new and improved clamp with that tab from Virginia went on a bit later, and that's what we're goin' with, as they say. I will remain jealous on how good those batteries still look though at the shows....
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: 5F08KGT on January 20, 2016, 07:47:39 AM
May be Excide should make a correct repro group 22F, 24F and 27F ??

There are other batteries on the market that still have the gusset, but they are few and far between.

Time will tell on the life with the Excides......40 month free replacement.......I've also got 2 group 65s in my 7.3 Diesel F350........
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: lancelot66 on January 20, 2016, 09:28:36 AM
I sure wish they'd consider it. They must have been making batteries for Napa at some point in time too. The battery I replaced had a case that was an identical match with the 7+ year old battery I'd bought new at Napa on the move up to Washington. Naturally, Napa no longer had the same ones, or even had a lip for the bracket on the current 24F's. I thought 7 years out of a battery wasn't too bad though.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: ChrisV289 on January 20, 2016, 09:37:24 AM
I needed to replace mine a couple of years ago and notice that O'reilly and AutoZone group 24 batteries were missing the lower lip for the batery hold down.  Of course the tried to push the generic over the top hold down which I declined.  I don't like the way those look on the early cars.  Pep Boys have a Bosch battery that has the lower lip as well.  That little lip is very important.  I've seen what happens when the battery isn't held down properly.  It can shift, fall on the alternator blade and then the blade chews through the battery spreading acid all over the engine bay.  Happened to my dad's 65 GT fastback.  It was a mess..
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: 67gtasanjose on January 20, 2016, 01:59:08 PM
... That little lip is very important.  I've seen what happens when the battery isn't held down properly.  It can shift, fall on the alternator blade and then the blade chews through the battery spreading acid all over the engine bay. 

Yep, been there, seen that...On my brother's 66 many moons ago he went too fast over a set or RR tracks...NOT PRETTY, I played "clean-up crew" on that one. :(
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: jwc66k on January 20, 2016, 04:29:18 PM
For 64-66, go to National Parts Depot - https://www.npdlink.com/store/ and call up bracket 10718-2A. You will also need 10718-2A, top piece, and 10756-1K, bolt kit. It's all bolt on, you will need a 1/4-20X1/2 bolt to attach the bracket to the battery tray. I've used them for years.
Jim
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Richard P. on January 20, 2016, 08:51:03 PM
Unfortunate but true. I had three Mustangs (one 65 Fastback, 2 66 Fastbacks) with reproduction Autolite type 27 batteries and they lasted about two-three years. The local Excide Battery guy was blunt, you need to drive the cars almost every day to keep that type of battery charged. That's the big secret. I thought a trickle charger would help, it didn't. I currently use a $100 battery with a 48 month warranty instead of a $250 battery with a 90 day warranty in each car. Economics 101.
Jim

Will the Autolite  type 27 battery fit a 1965/66 Mustang battery tray?
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Bob Gaines on January 20, 2016, 10:50:28 PM
Will the Autolite  type 27 battery fit a 1965/66 Mustang battery tray?
No or for 67/68 . Too long . Even in the 69 /70's there was a special tray for that large size.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: 5F08KGT on January 21, 2016, 07:38:34 AM
I simply cannot understand the need to make a reproduction case look right THEN put a wheelchair battery inside it with "an electronic devise"

What the hell is so secret about this electronic devise????  (STUPID)

Do the repro battery makers think they are doing us a favor by making these things? or are they just lining their pockets from OUR stupidity?

The concept of sealed batteries isn't new by any means, and I wouldn't think that making a correct battery case would be hard to do either, obviously they HAVE the molds to do this.......

And as far as ever seeing a correct group 22F battery properly reproduced, I don't think there is anywhere near enough demand for them......
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: ruppstang on January 21, 2016, 09:23:08 AM

And as far as ever seeing a correct group 22F battery properly reproduced, I don't think there is anywhere near enough demand for them......

The vast majority of the first generation cars used the 22F. I would think at least among the group on this forum there would be demand for them.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Bob Gaines on January 21, 2016, 10:39:06 AM
The vast majority of the first generation cars used the 22F. I would think at least among the group on this forum there would be demand for them.
+1 . Add more demand aside from this forum when many others are educated in knowing that the majority of 65-67 used the 22 as assemblyline
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: BobV on January 21, 2016, 08:15:20 PM
I think the battery manufacturers / Mustang parts houses are missing out here....

The only reason to have a correct appearing battery is for concours show use.
Plenty of people use old, dead batteries for show.

Why not just manufacture exact reproduction empty CASES for each year/group without any guts FOR SHOW USE?
If a user wants to modify it with a small cheater battery, make a kit available, or let me fill it with water/leave empty.
Can't be too outrageous to do, given all the 3D printers and open CNC machining time available.

I need a 1983-1986 BX-63 battery. DEAD ones run $500 (ridiculous IMHO). There are NO live ones available, so I'm stuck with either building a dummy OR using the "current" group 56, and/or lugging around a dead/gutted BX63 anyway. Since there is NO requirement for the battery to be functional, why not just build cases for show use and be done?  :o :P ;)
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Mike_B_SVT on January 22, 2016, 01:23:21 PM
I think the battery manufacturers / Mustang parts houses are missing out here....

The only reason to have a correct appearing battery is for concours show use.
Plenty of people use old, dead batteries for show.

Why not just manufacture exact reproduction empty CASES for each year/group without any guts FOR SHOW USE?
If a user wants to modify it with a small cheater battery, make a kit available, or let me fill it with water/leave empty.
Can't be too outrageous to do, given all the 3D printers and open CNC machining time available.

I need a 1983-1986 BX-63 battery. DEAD ones run $500 (ridiculous IMHO). There are NO live ones available, so I'm stuck with either building a dummy OR using the "current" group 56, and/or lugging around a dead/gutted BX63 anyway. Since there is NO requirement for the battery to be functional, why not just build cases for show use and be done?  :o :P ;)

That is a pretty good idea.  Lighter than a dead battery too.  Pretty plastic box of air... $75? 
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: 67gtasanjose on January 22, 2016, 02:18:39 PM

I need a 1983-1986 BX-63 battery. DEAD ones run $500 (ridiculous IMHO). There are NO live ones available...

I'd pay $500 for a 67 Assembly line 22F. Hook me up with a pallet load of them at that price ;)

... and they would all be sold again in no time at twice that!
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: C6ZZGT on May 29, 2016, 05:47:40 PM
Last time I needed a battery for my 66,i found the Motorcraft no longer had the lip on it so bought an AC Delco instead-it had the lip.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: KevinK on May 30, 2016, 01:23:51 AM
I think the battery manufacturers / Mustang parts houses are missing out here....

The only reason to have a correct appearing battery is for concours show use.
Plenty of people use old, dead batteries for show.

Why not just manufacture exact reproduction empty CASES for each year/group without any guts FOR SHOW USE?
If a user wants to modify it with a small cheater battery, make a kit available, or let me fill it with water/leave empty.
Can't be too outrageous to do, given all the 3D printers and open CNC machining time available.

I need a 1983-1986 BX-63 battery. DEAD ones run $500 (ridiculous IMHO). There are NO live ones available, so I'm stuck with either building a dummy OR using the "current" group 56, and/or lugging around a dead/gutted BX63 anyway. Since there is NO requirement for the battery to be functional, why not just build cases for show use and be done?  :o :P ;)

I suggested the empty plastic box idea a while back since none of the repo makers were interested in making any more model. There are plenty of actual battery power options to put inside the case. Seems simple to make cases.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Bob Gaines on May 30, 2016, 01:28:23 AM
I suggested the empty plastic box idea a while back since none of the repo makers were interested in making any more model. There are plenty of actual battery power options to put inside the case. Seems simple to make cases.
Kevin ,the injection molds to make the case is the expensive part not the internal battery.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: KevinK on May 30, 2016, 12:36:31 PM
Yes, Bob. I do realize there is still considerable expense in making them.  i guees I was hoping that we could get more suppliers interested by just dealing with a plastic box. It seems the battery guys are done developing products.
Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Rbisch4 on June 16, 2016, 06:28:24 PM
I am currently using on of the repo 24 batteries from http://www.restorationbattery.com.  Battery looks great and cranks my 351C 4V over every time I turn the key.  It only has been about 6 months and I am just finishing up the restoration so I do not have much long term testing to report on.  They were quick and responsive to questions about the battery and with the 4yr warranty I just could not resist having the original look under the hood.

Title: Re: Repro Battery
Post by: Building 3 on June 16, 2016, 07:11:38 PM
I bought my battery from from Antique Auto Battery in 2012. It came with a 4-year warranty.  It is an AGM type with 750 Cold Cranking Amps. I only put the AGM specific trickle charger on it when the voltage drops as indicated by my battery tester. The car gets driven once a week or so during the spring to the fall.  Then it sits the winter out. The charger has not been on it since March.  I use a battery disconnect when it sits in the garage.