OK, seeing other pictures with a similar cut at Marty described, I think I know now why he felt your 2nd console is broken off at the front.
I deffer to Marty's judging authority on this situation. It is very likely, that is just in my opinion, that the consoles could have been prepaired (cut as needed) in different manners.
I have bought and sold, installed or swapped several consoles over the years and have had more than just one example of the SHORTER version, exactly as pictured in the original post. I have referred to them as the A/C cut, never once believed them to be "broken". Mine is also exactly like that picture and when it was installed, I noticed nothing odd about fitment.
Again, I wish not to lead anyone down the wrong road. If the Judges believe the consoles must look as Marty indicated and that is the accepted version for Concours Judging, I will not defend my interpretation any longer.
If more unrestored examples can demonstrate that the shorter cut is acceptable, then so be it. Otherwise, I can only account for my own experience working on these since the mid-70's. I can attest that my example came to my ownership in the shorter, or "broken" version in 1978. If it defined as "broken", it was done before my taking ownership and it looks like a few others were all "broken" the exact same way. As for now, I intend on using the console I have, even if it is determined that it has been "broken". For now, in my opinion, I feel it is as it came fron San Jose only because it is as I recieved it as well as because I have seen enough other examples the exact same way, but mostly because I have never noticed anything odd in fitment in my car for all these years.
I hope that helps but truthfully, we need a Concours Judge to set the bar on this one I believe. Marty is a Gold Card judge and I am not.
Richard